Fireplaces, Heating Stoves, Flues and Chimneys - Need advice from the experts on Olympic wood burning insert
Doityourself.com community forum was created to provide answers to all questions related to home improvement and home repair. Doityourself community can help you find information about how-to topics on small fixes to large remodeling projects. With comprehensive how-to content and expertly moderated community forums DoItYourself.com makes it easy to tackle even the most complex home improvement projects.View Full Version : Need advice from the experts on Olympic wood burning insert
rbarline
09-21-09, 02:32 PM
I have my Olympic wood burning fireplace insert pulled out in order to clean the fireplace flue. This stove was in the house when we bought it and we have used it for over twenty years. This is the first time I have had it out or cleaned the flue, as it weighs a couple hundred pounds and is a monster to handle. I set up a little photo gallery so you can see what I am talking about in this post. My photos are located at my MobileMe Gallery (http://gallery.me.com/rbarline#100056) if you want to take a quick look.
I need some advice on a few questions regarding problems with down drafting, setting up external air intake for more efficient heating, and the need for a flue liner for safety.
Question 1: What causes smoke to downdraft in high winds? This usually happens when we are just starting the fire (so the flue is still cold and the fire is smokey). My wife thinks it indicates a defect in the seal between the Olympic and the fireplace, but upon inspection there is no space between the fiberglass insulation lining the fireplace (which is a heatilator by the way) and the insert, so I'm not buying it. My theory is that when the wind blows it draws air out of the house through the walls and causes a negative pressure inside the house. This theory is supported by the fact that the problem diminishes as the fire gets hotter (and the flue warms up creating more upward convection pressure to counter the negative pressure). So, am I right about this? If so, this brings me to my next question:
Question 2: What are the pros/cons of installing a system of outside air intake? My plan would be to use the existing ash clean out (which has a door on the floor of the fireplace and one outside at the base of the chimney). I can visualize a sheet metal duct that would be designed to bring air out to the front of the unit so that it would be available for intake to the stove, although there is no "intake" per se. My thinking is that not only would this displace warmed combustion air with cold, but would also allow an alternate source of outside air when the wind blows and creates negative pressure in the house (see question 1).
Question 3: In my situation, where the masonry chimney is on the exterior of the house (and assuming the ceramic flue liner is in good condition), is there a compelling need to add a metal flue liner? I understand that there is one wood wall in contact with the chimney, but it's a short chimney (see photos) so that risk is fairly minimal. Would adding a liner provide any other advantages beyond minimizing the risk of a fire in the attic? For example, would a liner help with questions 1 or 2?
Thanks for any assistance.
I need some advice on a few questions regarding problems with down drafting, setting up external air intake for more efficient heating, and the need for a flue liner for safety.
Question 1: What causes smoke to downdraft in high winds? This usually happens when we are just starting the fire (so the flue is still cold and the fire is smokey). My wife thinks it indicates a defect in the seal between the Olympic and the fireplace, but upon inspection there is no space between the fiberglass insulation lining the fireplace (which is a heatilator by the way) and the insert, so I'm not buying it. My theory is that when the wind blows it draws air out of the house through the walls and causes a negative pressure inside the house. This theory is supported by the fact that the problem diminishes as the fire gets hotter (and the flue warms up creating more upward convection pressure to counter the negative pressure). So, am I right about this? If so, this brings me to my next question:
Question 2: What are the pros/cons of installing a system of outside air intake? My plan would be to use the existing ash clean out (which has a door on the floor of the fireplace and one outside at the base of the chimney). I can visualize a sheet metal duct that would be designed to bring air out to the front of the unit so that it would be available for intake to the stove, although there is no "intake" per se. My thinking is that not only would this displace warmed combustion air with cold, but would also allow an alternate source of outside air when the wind blows and creates negative pressure in the house (see question 1).
Question 3: In my situation, where the masonry chimney is on the exterior of the house (and assuming the ceramic flue liner is in good condition), is there a compelling need to add a metal flue liner? I understand that there is one wood wall in contact with the chimney, but it's a short chimney (see photos) so that risk is fairly minimal. Would adding a liner provide any other advantages beyond minimizing the risk of a fire in the attic? For example, would a liner help with questions 1 or 2?
Thanks for any assistance.
rbarline
11-19-09, 02:24 PM
As a follow-up to this post I thought I would add that I decided to sell the old insert and buy a new one. I decided on the Avalon Olympic after some comparisons. One thing that pushed me over the edge to do this was the availability of a federal 30% income tax credit (not a deduction but a credit) on qualifying inserts. Ended up paying around $3,000 but got $900 back. Also, I decided to add a chimney liner kit which I got from Rockford Supply.
I did the installation of both the liner and stove myself; the only thing I had to hire out was the "torching out" of my heatilator metal firebox. This was necessary in order to remove the smoke shelf so I could run the flue liner down the chimney and position it to make connection to the new insert (this was the most difficult part because there is not enough clearance to reach inside and arrange the pipe once the stove is pushed in). By the way, this stove also comes with a knock-out on the bottom to allow for using outside air, which I did by removing the ash cleanout door on the floor of the fireplace.
Well, it's now in and I've had my first few fires and wow what a difference from my old stove. With secondary combustion it is very efficient and produces very little CO2 emissions. Of course dry wood and a hot fire is key to this too. I haven't used it in a high wind yet so I don't know if it will help that problem, but will find out this winter. I'll post back the results. Oh yeah, it's a gorgeous stove.
I did the installation of both the liner and stove myself; the only thing I had to hire out was the "torching out" of my heatilator metal firebox. This was necessary in order to remove the smoke shelf so I could run the flue liner down the chimney and position it to make connection to the new insert (this was the most difficult part because there is not enough clearance to reach inside and arrange the pipe once the stove is pushed in). By the way, this stove also comes with a knock-out on the bottom to allow for using outside air, which I did by removing the ash cleanout door on the floor of the fireplace.
Well, it's now in and I've had my first few fires and wow what a difference from my old stove. With secondary combustion it is very efficient and produces very little CO2 emissions. Of course dry wood and a hot fire is key to this too. I haven't used it in a high wind yet so I don't know if it will help that problem, but will find out this winter. I'll post back the results. Oh yeah, it's a gorgeous stove.