Electronic Alarms and Home Security Devices - Hardwired Vs Wireless
Doityourself.com community forum was created to provide answers to all questions related to home improvement and home repair. Doityourself community can help you find information about how-to topics on small fixes to large remodeling projects. With comprehensive how-to content and expertly moderated community forums DoItYourself.com makes it easy to tackle even the most complex home improvement projects.View Full Version : Hardwired Vs Wireless
dyi_zoz
05-22-08, 08:26 PM
I'm building a new home, so I have the choice to go either way (Hardwired or Wireless) personally I like the wireless option (like GE Simon XT), can you plz give your expert advise why I shouldn't or should.
What other wireless system that are good and recommended?
One more thing I noticed that Simon XT range is 1000 ft (I think in the open space), does anyone knows what that range would in a concret built home?.
Thx
What other wireless system that are good and recommended?
One more thing I noticed that Simon XT range is 1000 ft (I think in the open space), does anyone knows what that range would in a concret built home?.
Thx
MrRonFL
05-22-08, 08:45 PM
Wireless is pretty reliable, and the transmitters that GE uses have a pretty good track record.
If you _can_ go with hardwired, it really is the better choice. There's just fewer things to go wrong, and the overall hardware cost will be lower. Remember, each opening needs a transmitter, and they can add up. If it's a fairly small install, then it really will make no practical difference.
For the wireless range, take whatever the manufacturer specs, and figure on 2/3 of that in the real world.
If you _can_ go with hardwired, it really is the better choice. There's just fewer things to go wrong, and the overall hardware cost will be lower. Remember, each opening needs a transmitter, and they can add up. If it's a fairly small install, then it really will make no practical difference.
For the wireless range, take whatever the manufacturer specs, and figure on 2/3 of that in the real world.
dyi_zoz
05-23-08, 10:05 AM
Thanx A Lot Man, U Have Been A Great Help.
rjp01
05-23-08, 01:28 PM
Hardwired by a knockout...
No batteries at each sensor...
Virtually eliminate false alarms...
Cheaper to wire multiple windows....
Hidden window and door sensors....
Overall, wireless is better for a retrofit to an existing house where you don't want to wire through existing walls. Two or three sensor wireless systems are fairly cost effective.
One consideration: Look into monitoring costs carefully. That's the big money long term. I have seen monitoring for $5 a month to $29 per month. In reality, the monitoring is probably the same regardless. I pay $8 and they call within 60 seconds.
Also consider a cell phone back up phone link for monitored systems if highest security is desired. This will cost more over the traditional land line hookup.
No batteries at each sensor...
Virtually eliminate false alarms...
Cheaper to wire multiple windows....
Hidden window and door sensors....
Overall, wireless is better for a retrofit to an existing house where you don't want to wire through existing walls. Two or three sensor wireless systems are fairly cost effective.
One consideration: Look into monitoring costs carefully. That's the big money long term. I have seen monitoring for $5 a month to $29 per month. In reality, the monitoring is probably the same regardless. I pay $8 and they call within 60 seconds.
Also consider a cell phone back up phone link for monitored systems if highest security is desired. This will cost more over the traditional land line hookup.