Heat Pumps and Electric Heating - Honeywell CT3611R4450 to HW RTH3100c

First off, great site here, thanks for having me. I installed this CT stat in my father-in-laws house about 4 years ago, it went bad so he bought a RTH3100c. I installed it an have some issues, it will not come on in HEAT, it will come on in E-Heat, also when put in COOL the heat pump comes on. This is a Heat Pump unit with Electric heat strips. Heres the wiring for both stats.

OLD NEW
R R
C C
G G
O O
E E
Y/W1 Y
W2 Aux
Could anyone tell whats happening here, Thanks in advance !!! The book states of course that if old stat had W1,W2 and Y wires, contact heating/cooling contractor.I don't understand why the Y and W1 were jumpered on the CT stat from the factory either...

Okay, When I got home this evening I went through the stat setup again and entered electric furnace for both the Aux Heat and Emer-Heat parameters, the heat now works and E-Heat works but when put in A/C I still get heat pump, My guess is the Y and W2 wires should be together??? Please help !!!!

Thanks

What is the Make of the Heat Pump?

Make sure the O wire is by itself, and not touching anything else?

The outdoor unit is a Intertherm, but I found the problem, it was a bad thermostat, the O terminal wasn't making in the stat, therefore not energizing the reversing valve. I got a co-worker who is a licensed heating/air tech to come over and check it out. When I put the old stat on four years ago we got a bad stat(Honeywell also). Took it back and they gave me a new one identical in place of it and it worked fine. Anyway, I've got an old mercury switch on it now.

Thanks for your help anyway, Chris