Decks, Patios, Porches and Docks - Ipe vs. Mahogany
Doityourself.com community forum was created to provide answers to all questions related to home improvement and home repair. Doityourself community can help you find information about how-to topics on small fixes to large remodeling projects. With comprehensive how-to content and expertly moderated community forums DoItYourself.com makes it easy to tackle even the most complex home improvement projects.View Full Version : Ipe vs. Mahogany
mchristo
06-23-05, 11:10 PM
What is the difference between these Mahogany and Ipe Deck boards.
Does anyone know how the Mahogany fairs in the weather? I live in the Northeast (Ct.)
And has anyone purchased from IpeDepot.com? Their prices seem pretty good, but not sure if there are different qualities or grades?
Thanks,
Does anyone know how the Mahogany fairs in the weather? I live in the Northeast (Ct.)
And has anyone purchased from IpeDepot.com? Their prices seem pretty good, but not sure if there are different qualities or grades?
Thanks,
rdhamm
06-27-05, 10:55 AM
I have Ipe on a southern facing deck in Minnesota. I chose Ipe because it was cheaper and more available to me than Mahogany. I have photos here (http://home.comcast.net/~roger.hamm/Deck/hammdeck.html). It does need a new finish every year or so due to fading from the sun.
I bought my first load of Ipe from here (http://trimscrew.com/IPE.htm). You might want to call them. Their freight charges were really low, and sometimes they will have deals for certain length boards. I bought my 2nd load locally - I watched the classifieds in the paper and found some really cheap.
Post what you find out.
Good Luck.
I bought my first load of Ipe from here (http://trimscrew.com/IPE.htm). You might want to call them. Their freight charges were really low, and sometimes they will have deals for certain length boards. I bought my 2nd load locally - I watched the classifieds in the paper and found some really cheap.
Post what you find out.
Good Luck.
mchristo
06-27-05, 11:30 AM
Nice looking pics.
Are your boards #1 Premium or other?
Did you use the Ipe clips or some other hidden fasteners?
Also, it looks like you've got some cupping on some boards?
Will post my findings from my own research as well. thanks.
Mike.
Are your boards #1 Premium or other?
Did you use the Ipe clips or some other hidden fasteners?
Also, it looks like you've got some cupping on some boards?
Will post my findings from my own research as well. thanks.
Mike.
rdhamm
06-27-05, 12:19 PM
I did use Ipe clips, and I did suffer some cupping at the top of the stairs. I don't know how to get rid of it, so it stays. I actually don't recall the board quality - I know it is not select, and I doubt it is #2.
I recommend the bow-wrench. I did not have one for the first deck.
I recommend the bow-wrench. I did not have one for the first deck.
mchristo
06-27-05, 02:32 PM
don't think you can do anything about cupping, when it goes...it goes.
Did you use end sealer on cut boards?
The guys at IPEDepot.com strongly reccomended using sealer on any cut boards before installing it.
They are at 2.64 per linear foot plus $300 for delivery vs. 1.89 / ft for the mahogany and $25 for delivery.
urghhh these decisions are the worst part of the job for me!
Did you use end sealer on cut boards?
The guys at IPEDepot.com strongly reccomended using sealer on any cut boards before installing it.
They are at 2.64 per linear foot plus $300 for delivery vs. 1.89 / ft for the mahogany and $25 for delivery.
urghhh these decisions are the worst part of the job for me!
rdhamm
06-27-05, 03:34 PM
I used an emulsion wax end sealer. I even gorilla glued the boards to the joists. :(
jay_myself
07-02-05, 07:55 PM
I work for a lumberyard, (not a box store or discount lumber store). I stock IPE. As such, I can sell it for less than if it had to be special ordered. Lumber prices vary from one area to another, especially the left coast, where it is ridiculous.
If you are spending in the neighborhood of a couple thousand dollars, most yards will give you a discount. My normal list price for IPE is about what you quoted. But if a homeowner comes in to buy a deck package, I will generally give them close to a contractor's discount, bringing the lf price to $2.20. If they are reasonably close to my yard, (5-20 miles) and can live with "when convenient" delivery, they only pay a few bucks fuel surcharge and the actual delivery is free.
I would call around to a few lumber yards and ask if they stock IPE. Don't just ask the price, go in and talk to the salespeople. You will not get the best price on the phone.
If you are spending in the neighborhood of a couple thousand dollars, most yards will give you a discount. My normal list price for IPE is about what you quoted. But if a homeowner comes in to buy a deck package, I will generally give them close to a contractor's discount, bringing the lf price to $2.20. If they are reasonably close to my yard, (5-20 miles) and can live with "when convenient" delivery, they only pay a few bucks fuel surcharge and the actual delivery is free.
I would call around to a few lumber yards and ask if they stock IPE. Don't just ask the price, go in and talk to the salespeople. You will not get the best price on the phone.
mchristo
07-06-05, 07:17 PM
where is your lumberyard located? Maybe I'll drop in there?
I live in the Hartford Ct. area.
Thanks for the advice.
Mike.
I live in the Hartford Ct. area.
Thanks for the advice.
Mike.