questions re: tub & tub surround improvements

[familygal]

We need to update the main bathroom in a home we're buying. The tub finish and surround are in poor condition. Would a tub liner/surround combination be more economical than replacing the tub (We would probably have a professional do any work, unless it is very simple and quick). Also, can a surround be cut out around a window? Currently the bathroom window is covered by the surround, which we think is a shame. Finally, is there a specific type of contractor we should be looking for?

Thanks for your advice!

[isaacvs]

I would recommend a new tub over a liner. I also wouldn't recommend cutting out around the window.

If you really want the window back, you may consider (the expensive route) a tiled wall around the tub, or using a clawfoot tub that doesn't require a surround (but does require a shower curtain all the way around it).

[captwally]

If the tub is in good shape, but is just in need of cosmetic improvement, consider having it re-finished. You can find contractors to do this in the phone book. Steer away from a liner in the tub itself. Definitely replace the surround, as that is pretty inexpensive, and yes, you can cut out for the window. Just make sure you measure and cut properly, and then SEAL it properly. Tile is a good option, as Isaac said, but time consuming and more expensive.

[familygal]

Thanks for the replies to my first post. I'd originally thought we could just replace the tub because they're inexpensive. Then a neighbor warned us that replacing a tub can be costly because it entails redoing plumbing, replacing floor tiles, etc.

Both replies recommended tub refinishing or replacement over a liner. Can you elaborate as to why? How does a tub liner compare to a refinished tub in terms of durability. Could folks share their experience with liners? We have two young boys so I wonder if a refinished tub would hold up well for our family? We're just trying to figure out what option is best, taking both expense and durability into mind. If anyone has some knowledge about typical costs, that info would be appreciated too. Our bathroom is very small.

Thanks so very much!

[captwally]

Okay, picture it this way: You have a tub that is made of a solid material. If you put a liner over that, no matter how good the salesman says it is, you run the risk of having water trapped between your tub and the liner. If you have the tub refinished, you don't have to worry about that. A refinished tub is quite durable, even with two boys.

[familygal]

:) Thanks for your advice Wally.